When we welcomed our first child into the world, the concept of attachment parenting beckoned with its promise of deep connection and attunement. Eight years and three children later, we’ve experienced firsthand the profound benefits—and genuine challenges—of this approach. As parents who’ve lived the attachment journey, we’re sharing our insights into this sometimes misunderstood parenting philosophy.
Thank you for reading this post, don't forget to subscribe!
Understanding Attachment Parenting
Attachment parenting, popularized by pediatrician Dr. William Sears in the 1980s, centers on nurturing secure emotional bonds between parents and children. This approach emerged from attachment theory, developed by psychologist John Bowlby, which established that early, consistent responsiveness to a child’s needs forms the foundation for healthy emotional development.
The approach typically involves seven “Baby Bs” as described by Dr. Sears: birth bonding, breastfeeding, babywearing, bedsharing or close sleeping arrangements, belief in baby’s cries as communication, balance and boundaries, and beware of baby trainers. However, many parents adapt these principles to fit their family’s unique circumstances.
“Attachment parenting isn’t a checklist but rather a mindset of responsiveness and connection,” explains child development specialist Dr. Laura Markham. “The core is developing a secure attachment through consistently meeting your child’s needs with warmth and sensitivity.”
The Benefits We’ve Experienced
Stronger Emotional Security
Research consistently supports what we’ve observed in our children: responsive parenting builds secure attachment. A landmark study published in the journal Child Development found that securely attached children demonstrate greater emotional regulation, social competence, and cognitive development throughout childhood and into adulthood.
Our oldest child, who experienced the most consistent attachment parenting, approaches new situations with remarkable confidence. When facing challenges at school, he demonstrates resilience and seeks support appropriately—hallmarks of secure attachment according to research from the Harvard Center on the Developing Child.
Enhanced Brain Development
The physical closeness characteristic of attachment parenting—babywearing, responsive touch, and co-sleeping—supports optimal brain development. Neuroscientist Dr. Allan Schore’s research demonstrates that the consistent nurturing touch and emotional attunement fundamental to attachment parenting directly influences the development of the right brain, which governs emotional regulation and social connection.
We’ve witnessed this through our children’s ability to articulate complex emotions from an early age. By age three, our middle child could identify feelings of frustration, disappointment, and contentment—a vocabulary many adults struggle to access.
Reduced Stress and Anxiety
Studies measuring cortisol (the stress hormone) in infants show lower levels in babies whose cries receive prompt attention compared to those left to “cry it out.” Research published in the journal Biological Psychiatry indicates that responsive parenting helps infants develop more effective stress response systems that serve them throughout life.
“The responsive nature of attachment parenting helps children develop healthy stress response systems,” notes psychologist Dr. Darcia Narvaez, whose research at the University of Notre Dame examines evolutionary parenting practices. “This provides lifelong benefits for both physical and mental health.”
The Challenges We’ve Navigated
Physical and Emotional Exhaustion
The most significant challenge we encountered was the physical toll of constant responsiveness. During our second child’s infancy, sleep deprivation from night nursing and co-sleeping led to burnout that affected the entire family. A study in the Journal of Family Psychology confirms our experience isn’t unique—attachment parenting practices can contribute to parental fatigue and stress, particularly when support systems are limited.
We eventually modified our approach to include some gentle nighttime boundaries while maintaining responsiveness. This hybrid approach preserved our connection while protecting our health.
Balance with Other Relationships
Our marriage required intentional nurturing during intense attachment parenting phases. Research from the Gottman Institute demonstrates that marital satisfaction often declines during early parenthood, with the decline steeper for those practicing certain attachment parenting elements like co-sleeping.
“Attachment parenting doesn’t mean sacrificing all adult relationships,” explains family therapist Dr. John Gottman. “The most successful families find ways to maintain couple connections alongside parent-child bonds.”
We instituted weekly date nights and daily check-ins to preserve our relationship—efforts that ultimately supported our parenting by modeling healthy adult relationships for our children.
Societal Misunderstanding
Perhaps the most unexpected challenge came from external judgment. Friends, family, and even strangers questioned our choices about extended breastfeeding and babywearing. Research published in the Journal of Child and Family Studies confirms that parents practicing attachment approaches often face criticism from mainstream parenting circles.
We learned to respond confidently with research-backed explanations when appropriate, and simple “this works for our family” statements when necessary.
Transition Challenges
As our children grew, transitions sometimes proved difficult. Our son who co-slept until age four initially struggled with independent sleeping arrangements. However, research from developmental psychologist Dr. James McKenna suggests that children who experience secure attachment ultimately develop greater independence—on their own timetable.
True to this research, our now eight-year-old confidently navigates sleepovers and camp experiences, having developed independence at his own pace rather than through forced separation.
Finding Your Own Path
The beauty of attachment parenting lies in its adaptability. While the philosophy offers guiding principles, successful implementation looks different for every family.
“Parents should feel empowered to choose the elements that work for their unique situation,” advises family psychologist Dr. Shefali Tsabary. “The goal is connection, not perfection in following a prescribed set of practices.”
In our home, we embraced babywearing and responsive parenting wholeheartedly, modified co-sleeping to preserve parental well-being, and adapted breastfeeding duration for each child based on their needs and our circumstances.
Integration with Other Approaches
Many families successfully blend attachment principles with other parenting philosophies. We incorporated Montessori elements to foster independence alongside secure attachment, creating an environment where our children felt both connected and capable.
Research published in Early Childhood Research Quarterly suggests that combining responsive parenting with autonomy-supportive practices yields optimal developmental outcomes—children who feel secure enough to explore independently while knowing support remains available when needed.
Looking at the Long View
As our children grow, we see the fruits of attachment parenting in their emotional intelligence, secure relationships with peers, and confidence in expressing needs. Research tracking attachment-parented children into adolescence shows lower rates of behavioral problems, stronger academic performance, and healthier peer relationships compared to children raised with less responsive approaches.
“The investment in early attachment yields dividends throughout development,” explains Dr. Dan Siegel, clinical professor of psychiatry and author of “The Developing Mind.” “Secure attachment in childhood creates a foundation that supports healthy relationships throughout life.”
Is Attachment Parenting Right for Your Family?
This approach thrives on authenticity—parents must genuinely connect with the philosophy rather than following it from obligation. Research from the Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry indicates that parental authenticity significantly impacts effectiveness; children sense when parents’ actions align with their true values.
Before embracing attachment parenting, consider:
- Your family’s unique needs and circumstances
- Available support systems
- Your own childhood experiences and triggers
- Work obligations and practical constraints
- Each child’s individual temperament
The most successful attachment parents we know—ourselves included—approach these principles as guidelines rather than commandments, adapting practices to serve their family’s wellbeing while maintaining the core value of responsive connection.
By honoring both the profound benefits and real challenges of attachment parenting, families can create their own authentic path toward secure, nurturing relationships that support children’s development while sustaining parents’ wellbeing—truly the balanced approach that attachment parenting at its best can offer.
We hope it helps!
The Smart Parenting Blog Team
